Liverpool: FIFA Issues Harsh Verdict on Samuel Barrott and VAR Officials Over Controversial Merseyside Derby Decision

Sure! Here’s a paraphrased version of the article, keeping all quoted words intact:

—

**MediaBaze Sports**

**Liverpool: FIFA Delivers Stern Ruling on Samuel Barrott and VAR Team After Disputed Merseyside Derby Call**

admin | By admin | April 5, 2025 | No Comments | 3 Mins Read

After the heated Merseyside derby on April 2, 2025, between Liverpool and Everton, a disputed refereeing decision has stirred major controversy in the football world. The focal point of the debate was a forceful tackle by Everton skipper James Tarkowski on Liverpool’s Alexis Mac Allister in the early stages of the game. Tarkowski’s challenge made notable contact with Mac Allister’s lower leg, immediately raising alarm. Referee Samuel Barrott reacted by giving a yellow card, a call later confirmed by the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) headed by Paul Tierney.

The decision drew sharp backlash from supporters, ex-referees, and football analysts, many of whom felt the challenge warranted a red card. Mike Dean, formerly a Premier League official, was especially outspoken, showing shock that Barrott didn’t review the footage on the pitch-side screen. Dean called the challenge “horrible” and stressed that it deserved a sending off due to its severity. Analysts Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher shared this view on Sky Sports, describing the tackle as a potential “leg-breaker,” underlining how dangerous it was.

Amid the criticism, the Premier League released a formal statement in support of the officiating. The statement said the tackle was considered “reckless,” but didn’t cross the line into “excessive force” or “endangering an opponent”—criteria required for a red card. Still, this reasoning failed to ease frustration among fans and commentators. Concerns about the reliability and quality of officiating, especially regarding player safety and VAR implementation, remain widespread.

Luckily for Liverpool, Alexis Mac Allister avoided a major injury and continued after being treated. Liverpool ultimately secured a 1-0 win, thanks to Diogo Jota’s goal in the 57th minute. The result solidified Liverpool’s standing at the top of the Premier League, widening their lead over Arsenal to 12 points.

This episode has reignited ongoing debates about VAR’s function and the need for uniform decision-making in football. Critics warn that neglecting to penalize dangerous tackles correctly could encourage similar recklessness in future games. The pressure is growing on football’s governing bodies to review and refine current protocols to ensure fair play and better safeguard athletes on the pitch.

—

Let me know if you want a shorter version or need it tailored for a specific platform!